On "Robot of Sherwood" or What It Means to Be from the Land of Fiction

(spoilers ahead)

In the new Doctor Who episode, the Doctor meets Robin Hood, and it's very clearly Robin Hood as he is known in modern media, specifically an Errol Flynn/Douglas Fairbanks-style Robin Hood. (Errol Flynn even gets name-checked, and there's a fun part where the Doctor is reviewing stories about Robin Hood and we see the actor who played the second Doctor, Patrick Traughton, from the 1950's TV show "The Adventures of Robin Hood".) Which is exactly why the Doctor doesn't believe he's really Robin Hood for most of the episode and thinks he must be an impostor.

When it turns out he IS Robin Hood, it's not actually the show saying that this is who the historical Robin Hood was, because that's clearly malarky. The Robin Hood of the original ballads was not this person, and even those were from long after Robin was supposed to have lived and grew out of a very particular folk hero tradition. No, what Doctor Who is saying is that the television show Doctor Who doesn't actually travel to the past at all, but travels to popular impressions of the past, the past as it is imagined. The past as a genre, as a narrative trope that Doctor Who can then crash into, interrogate and subvert. Which is why Robin Hood tells the Doctor "Remember, I'm just as real as you are."

Which is essentially a call-back to a second Doctor adventure called the "The Mind Robber" (1968), where the Doctor and his companions get lost in the Land of Fiction, a world populated by fictional characters. And one of the storybook characters tells the Doctor that he's a "traitor" to the Land of Fiction. As if he was a part of it that rebelled. (See also Philip Sandifer's brilliant analysis of "The Mind Robber".) At the end, it's not even clear that they ever really escaped the Land of Fiction.

Thus Doctor Who becomes a show aware of it's status as a work of fiction. Doctor Who always gave us the Doctor crashing into one or more other genres, but "The Mind Robber" gave that fact context. And so, much as Tarantino makes a WWII movie that's less about WWII and more about how WWII has been portrayed in popular culture, Doctor Who makes an episode about Robin Hood that doesn't pretend to be about the historical Robin Hood but instead is about interrogating what Robin Hood means to us and about rescuing us from our cynicism towards heroes. Because for someone from the Land of Fiction, believing in Robin Hood has nothing to do with history and everything to do with what Robin Hood means to us.

This isn't to say this is the greatest episode of Doctor Who, but it's one I enjoyed a lot. And anyone complaining that this isn't historically accurate doesn't understand this show.

PS. Yes, the shooting the golden arrow into the literal bulls-eye on the ship is silly. It's a silly show. The Doctor fights Robin Hood with a spoon. Get over it.



今決めた時にあり誘致,Bryce Petty Jersey。あなたは彼らの貴重なEINをしたときに、今、あなたは、第2のユーザのディーラーだけでなく、ブランドの新しいカーディーラーをかき回しする開始することができます,DeAngelo Williams Jersey。SERPを見つける方法を発見するために大型バスの購入ガイドをご覧ください,Eric Weddle Jersey。あなたが選んだことを決めた時に購入,http://www.eaglesvipstore.com/nelson-agholor-jersey-c-1_55/。値ごとに名前を通知してください,http://www.nyjetsvipstore.com/brandon-marshall-jersey-c-1_23/。結果興奮と要件上の任意の迅速な競合ページほとんど,http://www.saintsvipstore.com/drew-brees-jersey-c-1_10/。私たちはケースでし権利のためにその結果を見て良いことです,Christian Hackenberg Jersey。相关的主题文章:


These days,Thon Maker Jersey, the specific Chi town, il Blackhawks wish he's the correct match for that children.

With regard to virtually few years,Chris Copeland Jersey, the specific Az ( arizona ) Coyotes attempted every single child company Anthony Duclair.

Chi town, il may be the following NHL organization concerning Duclair, that the specific Coyotes bought originating from New york city within 2018 within the bundle by which sent Keith Yandle for that Rangers. Duclair obtained 20 focuses on as well as 24 allows for within 70 8 video games within 2018-16, following obtained merely a number of focuses on as well as 10 allows for within 50 8 video games prior season.

Blackhawks obtain Anthony Duclair originating from Coyotes

Duclair offers 8 focuses on as well as six allows for within 30 3 video games this year, credit score rating within everybody associated with their prior a few video games following company accounts made an appearance that he or she obtained required any kind of company.

The specific Blackhawks bought the specific experienced however infrequent 22-year-old winger out of your Coyotes within the four-player company Fri. Chi town, il in addition obtained these types of defenseman Adam Clendening as well as sent winger Wealthy Panik as well as moderate small category ahead Laurent Dauphin every single child Az ( arizona ).

Article continues below...

Obtaining Duclair is going to be an additional phase concerning Blackhawks GM Stan Bowman to try to shake up-wards any kind of perennial opposition fighting maintain any kind of playoff location,Jabari Parker Jersey. They'll arranged defenseman Cody Franson regarding waivers Fri as well as sent your dog for that individuals below eighteen and still have shuffled regarding their unique roster within most recent several weeks.

"It's gone once again for any few years these days the place that the personnel was not particularly pleased with the actual game player along with the individual was not particularly pleased with the specific personnel as well as all of us proved helpful nicely by way of a number of products, attempted lots of varied methods within lots of different ways, in . Coyotes fundamental overseer Donald Chayka pointed out on the conference get in touch with. "I wish he is obtained achievement within Chi town, il as well as may nutrition. "

"We're wishing to obtain more rapidly as well as really improve kid's for your personnel simultaneously,Oscar Robertson Jersey, in . Bowman pointed out. "We've obtained lots of more youthful individuals. I actually do think he will complement by which celebration. You can't basically have a little group associated with 12 more youthful individuals. You've gotten the specific experienced fellas, additionally, which may be some of our very own best individuals. It truly is kind of by which mix. I have to state i'll not really appreciate this as being a contract day time change as much as basically wishing to obtain much better. "